The 70% Rule: How Ontario Investors Price Fixer-Uppers and Flips
If you buy fixer uppers or flip houses in Ontario, one number decides whether a deal makes money or drains it. That number is your maximum offer. Pay too much and the repair budget eats your profit. The 70 percent rule is the quick filter investors use to set that ceiling before they ever walk a property. It is not a law and it is not perfect. It is a starting point that stops you from overpaying on distressed properties and below-retail deals. Here is how the rule works and how to apply it to real Ontario markets.
What the 70% Rule Actually Says
The rule gives you a maximum allowable offer. The math is short. Take the after repair value of the property. Multiply it by 0.70. Then subtract your estimated repair costs. What is left is the most you should pay.
Maximum offer = (ARV x 0.70) minus repairs.
The 30 percent you hold back is not all profit. It covers closing costs, carrying costs, financing, resale fees, and the margin you want for taking the risk. Lenders and flipping guides like Rocket Mortgage and Kiavi describe the same formula, and most house flippers use some version of it. If you want the bigger picture on buying below retail, read our guide on how off-market buying works in Canada.
How to Estimate ARV in an Ontario Neighbourhood
ARV is what the home will sell for after it is fixed and looks like the other updated homes on the street. You do not guess it. You pull recent sold comparables.
Look for homes that sold in the last three to six months, within about one kilometre, similar in size, age, and layout, and already renovated to the standard you plan to hit. In dense markets like Toronto and the GTA you can stay tighter than a kilometre. In smaller Ontario towns you may need to widen the radius. Average the closest matches and that is your working ARV.
Be honest with the comps. A renovated semi does not sell for what a detached home sells for. The GTA average selling price sat near one million dollars in the fall of 2026 according to the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board, but that average hides big gaps between property types and pockets. Price the exact kind of home you will be reselling, not the market as a whole.
Getting the Repair Number Right
The repair estimate is where most new investors lose money. They lowball it. Build the number from real contractor pricing, not hope. As a rough planning guide, Canadian renovation costs in 2026 ran about like this, before tax (RenoQuotes, 2026):
- Light cosmetic work: roughly $10 to $45 per square foot
- Partial renovation with a kitchen and bathroom: roughly $55 to $140 per square foot
- Full gut renovation: roughly $150 to $260 per square foot and up
Major cities like Toronto tend to run 10 to 20 percent higher, and older homes can add another 15 to 25 percent for surprises behind the walls. At the room level in the Toronto area, renovators were quoting mid-range kitchens around $15,000 to $35,000 and full gut bathrooms around $18,000 to $30,000 in 2026 (RenoHouse, 2026). Always add a contingency of about 15 percent. Learning to tell a true handyman special from a money pit is what keeps that repair number realistic.
A Real Ontario Example, Step by Step
Say you find a dated detached home in a solid Ontario neighbourhood. Renovated homes like it are selling for $600,000. That is your ARV. Here is the full calculation.
- ARV: $600,000
- 70 percent of ARV: $420,000
- Estimated repairs: $80,000
- Maximum offer: $420,000 minus $80,000, which is $340,000
So $340,000 is your ceiling. If the seller wants $400,000, the deal does not work as a flip at this ARV. If you can buy it at $330,000 off market, you have room to work. Change any one input and the ceiling moves, which is why your comps and your repair estimate have to be tight.
Where the 70% Rule Bends in Ontario
The rule is a filter, not gospel. A few things move the number.
- Higher priced homes. On a large Toronto or GTA ARV, 70 percent can leave more cushion than you need, so some buyers stretch to 75 percent.
- Lower priced homes. In markets with cheap houses and fixer uppers, like parts of Windsor or Northern Ontario, fixed costs eat a bigger share, so you may need to drop to 65 percent.
- Buy and hold. If you plan to keep the property as a rental instead of flipping it, positive cash flow matters more than resale margin. In that case lean on a proper rental analysis rather than the 70 percent rule.
Use the rule to decide fast which leads are worth a deeper look. Then underwrite the winners properly.
Why Off-Market Deals Are Where the Math Works
Run the 70 percent rule on listed, renovated homes and almost nothing passes. Retail buyers bid those up. The math only works when you buy below retail, and that usually means off-market deals and wholesale properties.
Those deals come from motivated sellers who value speed and certainty over top dollar. Estates, tired landlords, distressed properties, and homes that need too much work for a regular buyer. That discount is the room your 70 percent calculation needs. It is also what we focus on. Jania Group is a real estate investor and buyer, not an agent or brokerage. We source off-market deals across Ontario, including flip-ready Hamilton projects you can read more about in our Hamilton fixer-upper guide, and we pass them to our buyer list first.
Join the Ontario Buyer List
You do not have to find these deals on your own. We send off-market and wholesale properties straight to cash buyers and investors before they go anywhere else. You run your own numbers, including your 70 percent rule, and decide. There is no pressure and no fee to join.
Tell us the kind of deals you want and the Ontario markets you want them in. We will start sending below-retail and off-market opportunities that fit your buy box.
This article is general information for investors and is not legal, tax, or financial advice. Always confirm the details of any purchase with a licensed professional in your province.